Should Game Freak remake Pokémon Black and Pokémon White for the Nintendo Switch 2?

Current Context

• Nintendo Switch 2 Launch: The Nintendo Switch 2 is set to be released in 2025, with speculation pointing towards a launch window around May or June This timing aligns with the anticipation for new titles to accompany the console's debut.
• Existing Speculation: Recent leaks, particularly from the Pokémon HOME app, hint at a connection to Pokémon Black and White, suggesting that these titles could see modern remakes on the new console The year 2026 marks the 30th anniversary of the Pokémon franchise, which could serve as a strategic release window for such remakes.

Arguments for Remakes

• Popularity and Nostalgia: Pokémon Black and White are beloved entries in the franchise, noted for their strong narrative and character development. Remaking these games would cater to both nostalgic fans and new players looking for updated experiences
• Technological Advancements: The Switch 2 promises enhanced graphics and gameplay mechanics, which could significantly improve the experience of these classic titles. Fans are eager to see how Game Freak would leverage modern technology to enhance gameplay and visuals
• Incorporation of Sequels: There is potential for Game Freak to not only remake the original games but also integrate elements from their sequels (Black 2 and White 2), possibly offering a comprehensive package that includes expanded storylines and additional content

Counterarguments

• No Immediate Need: Some argue that while remakes are desirable, they are not strictly necessary given that the original games still hold up well. The focus might instead shift towards new entries in the series, such as potential sequels or spin-offs
• Market Strategy: There is speculation that Game Freak might prioritize other projects or remakes before revisiting Black and White, especially considering the pattern of releasing remakes based on older generations first

Conclusion